Thursday June 22, 2006 | The Horseless Library Digital Library Discussions |
|
Last month, I started using an IBM Lenovo Tablet PC at work. Our Head of I.T., another Tablet owner, warned me that Tablets are like magnets. He said that people - strangers - would now stop me everywhere I went, and he was right. I am now stopped consistently in the airport, approached on the street, and interrupted in coffee shops by people interested in the Tablet or, it sometimes seems, just interested in chatting and using the Tablet as an ice-breaker. When I attended the Educause Southeast Regional Conference in Atlanta this week, I had a particularly interesting Tablet-related experience. I took all my notes for the Conference on the Lenovo. I love the flexibility of stylus-based, handwriting recognition text entry. Now I can draw diagrams in my notes, write in the margins of electronic documents, basically doing anything I can do with pen and paper, and have a digital file as the end product. So, I attended a large-group discussion on Tuesday and the session was generating lots of input from the participants. Suddenly, the facilitator stopped the conversation mid-stream and asked if someone would volunteer to take notes and capture all the ideas bouncing around. I am not much of a note-taker, and I confess to looking down at my feet when this request was made. The room was silent for a long time and when I looked up, the entire room was looking at me and smiling. We all started laughing, and the facilitator said 'Would you mind?' This situation was strange to me because so many other people in the room were taking notes on pen and paper or on their laptops. I didn't know a soul in the room, while many of the other attendees seemed to know each other well. I was participating vocally like everyone else. I could only think that the Tablet made me the unanimous note-taker choice. I thought maybe people saw me scribbling with my stylus, so it was obvious that I was taking notes already. But, like I said, there were plenty of people writing on pads of paper. Then, I thought, maybe I was singled out because my notes were digital. But, what about all those laptop users in the room? Aren't typewritten notes going to be more legible anyway? Maybe participants assumed that the laptop users were really just websurfing, checking email, or doing other work? Do people just identify the tablet as a specialized 'note-taking' tool - moreso than a legal pad and ballpoint pen? This phenomenon is interesting to me because librarians often deal with 'approachability' issues at the reference or information desk. The nature of library work now requires some sort of computer at these service desks. However, patrons feel uncomfortable approaching librarians who are working on or sitting at a computer. Maybe librarians need to carry Tablets at these service points instead? Post a Comment: Comments are closed for this entry. |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Interesting, Joe. I wonder if you're right about staff using tablets (or even just wireless laptops) at service desks? The back of a big monitor sure seems like a sight-line / approachability issue to me. Would tablets or wireless laptops on a desk look different to patrons? Different enough to make a difference? What if you took the desk away and just put the libarian at a table or kiosk with a tablet?
Even if you assume the librarian is at a traditional desk, laptops would cut away the anchor of the wired desktop computer. Roving around while on reference duty is something I like in theory but am uncomfortable with in practice. I think part of that is my knowledge that should I find someone to help while roving, I'll just have to drag them back to the big computer at the desk. If I could easily carry my "desk computer" with me, that would change the equation.
Back to tablets and note-taking. You're working a reference shift, roving around. You've found a patron who needs help. If she has a tough question or if you have a complicated answer that needs writing down or includes lengthy URLs, you make notes on the spot (the spot where you found her, not at the desk), email them to her and/or yourself for later.
Posted by Josh Boyer on June 22, 2006 at 11:37 AM EDT #
Interesting story! And useful to think about towards approachability issues. As far as reference desk assistance goes, while I understand that studies show that people may not approach us if we're on a computer, anecdotally it's hard for me to agree. When I'm using the computer I feel like people will ask me questions, whereas people feel like they're interrupting me if I'm doing something more 'analog' like reading a book or writing something, or even just standing there (perhaps I appear too eager?).
Posted by Josh Wilson on June 28, 2006 at 11:02 AM EDT #